Avoiding Ethics Violations in Practice

Engineering decisions shape the world around us, from the bridges we cross to the software that runs our daily lives. Yet almost two-thirds of employees (a global median of 65%) said that within the last 12 months, they observed at least one act that they deemed to be a violation of their organization's standards or the law, according to the Ethics & Compliance Initiative. 

For engineering professionals in the United States, understanding how to navigate ethical challenges isn't simply about compliance; it's about protecting public safety, maintaining professional credibility, and building a sustainable career. This article examines the most common ethics pitfalls facing engineers today and provides actionable strategies to avoid them while fulfilling your professional obligations.

Understanding the Foundation: What Constitutes an Ethics Violation

According to analysis from the Texas Board of Professional Engineers' disciplinary records, the most frequent ethics violations include:

• Practicing without a license - Often, administrative errors occur where engineers fail to renew their license by the deadline, but continue providing services

• Negligence - including errors, omissions, and performing work outside the area of expertise

• Improper use of seal and/or title block - Failing to stamp drawings, using seals when work wasn't performed or supervised by the engineer

• Continuing education violations - Failing to earn required credits or falsely reporting completion

• Felony convictions - Criminal activity that undermines public trust in the profession

• False statements - Including deceptive business practices, false advertising, and undisclosed conflicts of interest

For engineers looking to understand real-world scenarios involving improper payments and conflicts of interest, Engineering Ethics Case Studies in Bribery provides a detailed analysis of actual cases and their consequences.

Real-World Consequences

Recent high-profile cases demonstrate the severe consequences of ethics violations. RTX subsidiary Raytheon paid more than $950 million to resolve charges of defective pricing fraud and violations of the Foreign Corrupt Practices Act, reports Ethisphere. For individual engineers, violations can result in license suspension, career limitations, and personal liability with penalties ranging from written reprimands to permanent license revocation.

Ethics violations often arise from gray areas where good intentions meet poor judgment. The foundation of ethical practice lies in transparency, competence within your field, and prioritizing public welfare over personal or business interests.

When Engineers Overreach Their Expertise

One of the most dangerous misconceptions in engineering practice is the belief that a Professional Engineer (PE) license grants unlimited expertise across all engineering disciplines. Many charges are related to engineers practicing outside their area of competence, yet this violation often stems from business pressures rather than intentional deception.

The Pressure to Overreach

The pressure to say "yes" to lucrative projects outside your specialty area is real. Clients may approach you with urgent deadlines, competitive bidding situations, or long-standing relationships that make it difficult to turn down work. However, the consequences of overreaching can be catastrophic.

Historical disasters like the Hyatt Regency walkway collapse, which killed 114 people and injured 216 others, resulted from engineers signing off on work they didn't directly oversee. The walkway design violated weight-bearing codes, but a lack of proper communication and oversight led to the tragic failure, according to Case Western Reserve University.

Building Competency Safeguards

The solution requires both professional discipline and business strategy. Before accepting any project, conduct an honest assessment of your competency:

• Protection of Public Health, Safety, Welfare - Is this work within your demonstrated expertise?

• Education and Experience - Can you document relevant qualifications in this specific area?

• Professional competence - Are you current with standards and best practices?

Understanding intellectual property protection and confidentiality requirements is crucial for engineers working across different sectors. Engineering Ethics Case Studies in Espionage examines real cases where engineers faced complex decisions about protecting sensitive information and trade secrets.

State-Specific Requirements and Practical Applications

Ethics compliance varies significantly across states, making it crucial to understand your specific jurisdiction's requirements. Many states require 1–4 hours in ethics or professional responsibility as part of their Professional Development Hour (PDH) requirements.

State Requirements by Jurisdiction

• Texas: 15 PDH hours annually with at least one hour dedicated to ethics, broadly defined to include Texas engineering laws, the Engineering Practice Act, Board rules, and case studies addressing ethics and professional behavior.

• Minnesota: 24 PDH hours biennially with 2 hours dedicated to professional ethics courses, which don't need to be engineering-specific but must improve public welfare, safety, and health.

• Wisconsin: 30 PDH hours biennially with a minimum of 2 hours of continuing education in ethics and professional conduct.

• New Jersey: 24 PDH hours biennially with 2 hours of continuing education credit specifically in ethics.

PE Courses provides state-specific guidance to help engineers understand their exact requirements across all 50 states.

Industry-Specific Challenges

The regulatory landscape extends beyond continuing education. Statistics show that corruption can inflate project costs by up to 30%, diverting vital resources from infrastructure and essential public services. Recent challenges to enforcement mechanisms make personal ethical standards even more critical.

Boeing's ongoing challenges, stemming from the erosion of its once-vaunted "engineer culture" that placed a premium on safety, demonstrate how ethical failures can destroy decades of reputation and public trust, reports Ethisphere.

Actionable Compliance Strategies

• Documentation: Maintain detailed records of all decisions, communications, and project parameters. Many states conduct random audits and expect accurate records for 3–5 years.

• Conflict Disclosure: Establish written procedures for identifying and disclosing potential conflicts of interest to all parties before they become violations.

• Competency Verification: Create a systematic process for evaluating project requirements against your documented qualifications before proposing or accepting work.

• Regular Ethics Training: Exceed minimum requirements by participating in comprehensive courses that cover fundamental principles and real-world applications. Engineering Ethics: An Essential Overview of the Practice provides thorough coverage of ethical frameworks and decision-making processes.

• Professional Development Resources: The National Society of Professional Engineers and state engineering boards offer comprehensive ethics courses. The American Society of Civil Engineers maintains an extensive database of ethical case studies at its "A Question of Ethics" archive.

For comprehensive professional development, PE Courses offers specialized packages designed specifically to meet state licensing requirements while building practical competency.

Building an Ethical Engineering Practice

Creating Sustainable Ethical Practices

• Establish Clear Boundaries: Define your areas of competence explicitly and communicate them clearly to clients and colleagues.

• Maintain Transparency: Document all potential conflicts of interest and disclose them proactively to affected parties.

• Prioritize Public Welfare: When business pressures conflict with safety or ethical standards, remember that your professional obligation is to protect public health, safety, and welfare.

• Invest in Ongoing Education: Regular ethics training helps you recognize emerging ethical challenges and develop frameworks for addressing them effectively.

Professional Development Investment

Remember that ethical engineering practice isn't just about avoiding violations; it's about actively contributing to public welfare and maintaining the trust that society places in our profession. Consider comprehensive ethics education that goes beyond minimum requirements.

Conduct an ethics audit of your current practice. Review your last five projects for potential competency, conflict, or communication issues. Then invest in ethics education that goes beyond the minimum requirements; your license, reputation, and the public you serve all depend on it.

Visit PE Courses to explore comprehensive continuing education options tailored to US licensing requirements and professional growth. For a limited time, you can use code JULY-25 for 15% off all courses.